Find flights
Deals
Insights
When to book
FAQs & Tips
Direct Flights
Airlines

NYC - MVY

$207 Find Cheap Flights from New York to West Tisbury

This is the cheapest one-way flight price found by a KAYAK user in the last 72 hours by searching for a flight from New York to West Tisbury departing on 5/3. Fares are subject to change and may not be available on all flights or dates of travel. Click the price to replicate the search for this deal.
1 adult
0 bags

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to West Tisbury

 
These are the airlines KAYAK users have selected most often from within our search results in flight searches from New York to West Tisbury, as well as popular online travel agencies
These are the airlines KAYAK users have selected most often from within our search results in flight searches from New York to West Tisbury, as well as popular online travel agencies
In the last 7 days travelers have searched 43,377,091 times on KAYAK, and here is why:

Save 22% or moreCompare multiple travel sites with one search.

Track pricesNot ready to book? Create a price alert for when prices drop.

Filter your dealsChoose cabin class, free Wi-Fi and more.

Bundle and saveSave money when you bundle your flight + hotel.

World’s Best Airfare Search Site for 2024

Cheap Flight Deals from New York to West Tisbury (NYC-MVY)

 
These are the cheapest deals for flights from New York to West Tisbury currently on KAYAK along with options from the most popular airlines KAYAK users selected for this route. While these flights were available on KAYAK in the last 72 hours, prices and availability are subject to change and deals may expire.

Recent round-trip flight deals from New York to West Tisbury

Recommended round-trip deals departing in the coming months from the most popular airlines that fly from New York to West Tisbury.

Recent one-way flight deals from New York to West Tisbury

Only flying one-way? Below are some of the best one-way flight deals from New York to West Tisbury found on KAYAK recently.

Recent last minute flight deals from New York to West Tisbury

Leaving soon but still want a bargain? Check out these latest deals for last minute flights from New York to West Tisbury.

Recent direct flight deals from New York to West Tisbury

The latest deals for direct flights from New York to West Tisbury so you can sit back and relax without the need for a layover.

Cheap bus & train deals from New York to West Tisbury

Find recent round-trip train or bus tickets from New York to West Tisbury.

All round-trip flight deals to West Tisbury

The cheapest plane tickets to West Tisbury found on KAYAK recently.
Discover the best prices and deals for you by selecting your travel dates.
Choose your dates
9:30 am - 7:45 amLGA-MVY
22h 15m1 stop
1:05 pm - 7:29 amMVY-LGA
18h 24m1 stop
$513JetBlue
Find Deal
Fri, Dec 27 - Mon, Dec 30
10:50 am - 4:30 pmJFK-MVY
5h 40m1 stop
5:30 pm - 10:13 pmMVY-JFK
4h 43m1 stop
$514JetBlue
Find Deal
Thu, Dec 19 - Sun, Dec 22
6:00 pm - 7:45 amJFK-MVY
13h 45m1 stop
5:30 pm - 10:00 pmMVY-JFK
4h 30m1 stop
$545JetBlue
Find Deal
Fri, Dec 27 - Mon, Dec 30
1:50 pm - 5:48 pmJFK-MVY
3h 58m1 stop
7:30 am - 12:45 pmMVY-JFK
5h 15m1 stop
$554JetBlue
Find Deal
Sat, Jan 18 - Mon, Jan 20
10:50 am - 2:10 pmJFK-MVY
3h 20m1 stop
4:50 pm - 10:13 pmMVY-JFK
5h 23m1 stop
$563JetBlue
Find Deal
Sat, Dec 21 - Tue, Dec 24
9:30 am - 1:20 pmLGA-MVY
3h 50m1 stop
5:30 pm - 9:48 pmMVY-LGA
4h 18m1 stop
$568JetBlue
Find Deal
Thu, Dec 19 - Sun, Dec 22
2:48 pm - 5:48 pmEWR-MVY
3h 00m1 stop
7:30 am - 10:50 amMVY-EWR
3h 20m1 stop
Sat, Jan 18 - Mon, Jan 20
11:55 am - 6:58 amJFK-MVY
19h 03m1 stop
7:28 pm - 11:00 amMVY-JFK
15h 32m1 stop
$762Cape Air
Find Deal
Sat, Nov 16 - Fri, Nov 22
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
7:28 pm - 11:00 amMVY-JFK
15h 32m1 stop
$775Cape Air
Find Deal
Mon, Nov 18 - Fri, Nov 22
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
7:28 pm - 11:00 amMVY-JFK
15h 32m1 stop
$784Cape Air
Find Deal
Mon, Nov 18 - Tue, Nov 19
6:00 am - 10:20 amJFK-MVY
4h 20m1 stop
$207JetBlue
Find Deal
Sat, May 3
6:00 am - 9:50 amJFK-MVY
3h 50m1 stop
$237JetBlue
Find Deal
Wed, Dec 4
9:30 am - 1:20 pmLGA-MVY
3h 50m1 stop
$237JetBlue
Find Deal
Wed, Dec 4
7:59 am - 11:45 amLGA-MVY
3h 46m1 stop
$247JetBlue
Find Deal
Sat, May 3
12:30 pm - 4:30 pmJFK-MVY
4h 00m1 stop
$277JetBlue
Find Deal
Thu, Dec 5
10:59 am - 4:30 pmLGA-MVY
5h 31m1 stop
$277JetBlue
Find Deal
Thu, Dec 5
10:27 am - 5:10 pmLGA-MVY
6h 43m2 stops
Mon, Feb 3
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
$410Cape Air
Find Deal
Thu, Jan 2
11:55 am - 6:58 amJFK-MVY
19h 03m1 stop
$431Cape Air
Find Deal
Sun, Dec 1
12:55 pm - 7:05 pmJFK-MVY
6h 10m2 stops
$459Cape Air
Find Deal
Mon, Nov 18
10:55 pm - 9:50 amEWR-MVY
10h 55m1 stop
11:30 am - 9:00 amMVY-EWR
21h 30m2 stops
Tue, Nov 5 - Fri, Nov 8
6:30 am - 11:18 amEWR-MVY
4h 48m2 stops
7:28 pm - 1:01 pmMVY-EWR
17h 33m2 stops
Tue, Nov 5 - Fri, Nov 8
6:30 am - 10:30 amLGA-MVY
4h 00m1 stop
7:20 am - 10:17 amMVY-LGA
2h 57m1 stop
$813JetBlue
Find Deal
Fri, Nov 8 - Sun, Nov 10
6:30 am - 10:30 amEWR-MVY
4h 00m1 stop
5:30 pm - 7:29 amMVY-EWR
13h 59m1 stop
Fri, Nov 8 - Sun, Nov 10
7:30 am - 10:30 amJFK-MVY
3h 00m1 stop
7:20 am - 11:00 amMVY-JFK
3h 40m1 stop
$848JetBlue
Find Deal
Fri, Nov 8 - Sun, Nov 10
7:30 am - 10:30 amJFK-MVY
3h 00m1 stop
9:52 am - 11:15 amMVY-JFK
1h 23mnonstop
$861JetBlue
Find Deal
Fri, Nov 8 - Sun, Nov 10
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
9:52 am - 11:15 amMVY-JFK
1h 23mnonstop
$898JetBlue
Find Deal
Sat, Nov 9 - Sun, Nov 10
12:55 pm - 9:05 amJFK-MVY
20h 10m2 stops
7:35 pm - 11:00 amMVY-JFK
15h 25m1 stop
$910Cape Air
Find Deal
Sat, Nov 9 - Sun, Nov 10
11:55 am - 9:36 amJFK-MVY
21h 41m2 stops
7:35 pm - 11:00 amMVY-JFK
15h 25m1 stop
$955Cape Air
Find Deal
Fri, Nov 8 - Sun, Nov 10
12:55 pm - 9:05 amJFK-MVY
20h 10m2 stops
5:30 pm - 12:25 pmMVY-JFK
18h 55m2 stops
$1,027Cape Air
Find Deal
Sat, Nov 9 - Sun, Nov 10
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
9:52 am - 11:15 amMVY-JFK
1h 23mnonstop
$848JetBlue
Find Deal
Tue, Nov 19 - Thu, Nov 21
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
9:52 am - 11:15 amMVY-JFK
1h 23mnonstop
$856Cape Air
Find Deal
Thu, Nov 14 - Mon, Nov 18
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
9:52 am - 11:15 amMVY-JFK
1h 23mnonstop
$866Cape Air
Find Deal
Tue, Dec 24 - Thu, Dec 26
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
9:52 am - 11:15 amMVY-JFK
1h 23mnonstop
$869Cape Air
Find Deal
Mon, Nov 18 - Thu, Nov 21
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
9:52 am - 11:15 amMVY-JFK
1h 23mnonstop
$870Cape Air
Find Deal
Thu, Nov 21 - Sat, Nov 23
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
9:52 am - 11:15 amMVY-JFK
1h 23mnonstop
$898JetBlue
Find Deal
Sun, Nov 17 - Fri, Nov 22
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
9:52 am - 11:15 amMVY-JFK
1h 23mnonstop
$916Cape Air
Find Deal
Thu, Nov 28 - Fri, Nov 29
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
9:52 am - 11:15 amMVY-JFK
1h 23mnonstop
$920Cape Air
Find Deal
Tue, Nov 19 - Sat, Nov 23
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
9:52 am - 11:15 amMVY-JFK
1h 23mnonstop
$922Cape Air
Find Deal
Mon, Nov 18 - Fri, Nov 22
12:10 pm - 1:23 pmJFK-MVY
1h 13mnonstop
9:52 am - 11:15 amMVY-JFK
1h 23mnonstop
$966Cape Air
Find Deal
Wed, Nov 20 - Sun, Nov 24

Flights from New York to West Tisbury - Travel Insights & Trends

Get data-powered insights and trends into flights from New York to West Tisbury to help you find the cheapest flights, the best time to fly and much more.

What is the cheapest New York to West Tisbury flight route?

The cheapest price for flight routes found by users searching on KAYAK in the last 2 weeks for one-way flights from New York to West Tisbury.
Our data shows that the cheapest route for a one-way flight from New York to West Tisbury cost $88 and was between New York John F Kennedy Intl Airport and West Tisbury. On average, the best prices are found if you fly from New York LaGuardia Airport to West Tisbury. The average price for a return flight for this route is $176.

What’s the cheapest day of the week to fly from New York to West Tisbury?

The average price of all flights from New York to West Tisbury clicked on KAYAK for each day over the last 12 months.
Your flight ticket price will generally be cheaper if you fly to West Tisbury on a Monday and more expensive on a Friday. On your return trip to New York, you should consider flying back on a Monday, and avoid Sundays for better deals.

How far in advance should I book a flight from New York to West Tisbury?

To calculate daily average prices, KAYAK takes all prices for each day before departure over the last year for flights from New York to West Tisbury, removes the top 0.1% to account for outliers, and then takes the average of all the values for each month.
To get a below average price on the flight from New York to West Tisbury, you should book around 3 days before departure. For the absolute cheapest price, our data suggests you should book 114 days before departure.

Good to know

Low season

June

High season

August

Cheapest flight

$207
Best time to beat the crowds with an average 51% drop in price.
Most popular time to fly and prices are also 42% lower on average.
Flight from New York John F Kennedy Airport to West Tisbury

When to book flights from New York to West Tisbury

Are your dates flexible? Find out the best times to travel from New York to West Tisbury based on our flight data from the last year. Discover the cheapest month and even day to fly.
Estimated round-trip price
KAYAK looks at all historical flight data for each date to provide a predicted price for one-way trips or round-trips with a duration up to 40 days. While we try to provide actual minimum prices for each date, some prices are predictions and actual prices may differ.

FAQs for booking flights from New York to West Tisbury

  • What is the cheapest flight from New York to West Tisbury?

    In the last 3 days, the lowest price for a flight from New York to West Tisbury was $207 for a one-way ticket and $513 for a round-trip.

  • Do I need a passport to fly between New York and West Tisbury?

    No

  • Which airports will I be using when flying from New York to West Tisbury?

    There are 3 airports in New York (Newark, New York John F Kennedy Intl, and New York LaGuardia.) and only 1 airport in West Tisbury (West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard). The cheapest flights are generally found on the New York John F Kennedy Airport to West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard flight route.

  • Which airlines offer Wi-Fi service onboard planes from New York to West Tisbury?

    JetBlue, Delta, American Airlines, and Alaska Airlines offer inflight Wi-Fi service on the New York to West Tisbury flight route.

  • Which aircraft models fly most regularly from New York to West Tisbury?

    The Embraer 175 is the aircraft model that flies most regularly on the New York to West Tisbury flight route.

  • On which days can I fly direct from New York to West Tisbury?

    There are nonstop flights from New York to West Tisbury on a daily basis.

  • Which is the best airline for flights from New York to West Tisbury, Cape Air or JetBlue?

    The two airlines most popular with KAYAK users for flights from New York to West Tisbury are Cape Air and JetBlue. With an average price for the route of $803 and an overall rating of 8.9, Cape Air is the most popular choice. JetBlue is also a great choice for the route, with an average price of $308 and an overall rating of 7.5.

  • How does KAYAK find such low prices on flights from New York to West Tisbury?

    KAYAK is a travel search engine. That means we look across the web to find the best prices we can find for our users. With over 2 billion flight queries processed yearly, we are able to display a variety of prices and options on flights from New York to West Tisbury.

  • How does KAYAK's flight Price Forecast tool help me choose the right time to buy my flight ticket from New York to West Tisbury?

    KAYAK’s flight Price Forecast tool uses historical data to determine whether the price for a flight to West Tisbury from New York is likely to change within 7 days, so travelers know whether to wait or book now.

  • What is the Hacker Fare option on flights from New York to West Tisbury?

    Hacker Fares allow you to combine one-way tickets in order to save you money over a traditional round-trip ticket. You could then fly to West Tisbury with an airline and back to New York with another airline.

  • What is KAYAK's "flexible dates" feature and why should I care when looking for a flight from New York to West Tisbury?

    Sometimes travel dates aren't set in stone. If your preferred travel dates have some wiggle room, flexible dates will show you all the options when flying to West Tisbury from New York up to 3 days before/after your preferred dates. You can then pick the flights that suit you best.

See more FAQs

KAYAK’s top tips for finding a cheap flight from New York to West Tisbury

  • Looking for a cheap flight? 25% of our users found flights on this route for $88 or less one-way and $221 or less round-trip.

Prefer to fly non-stop from New York to West Tisbury?

Find which airlines fly direct from New York to West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard Airport, which days they fly and book direct flights.

Nonstop departures

New York to West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard

Monday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

Tuesday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

Wednesday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

Thursday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

Friday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

Saturday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

Sunday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

See more direct flights

Nonstop returns

West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard to New York

Monday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

Tuesday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

Wednesday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

Thursday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

Friday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

Saturday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

Sunday

Cape Air, JetBlue

Cape Air, JetBlue

See more direct flights
See more direct flights

Top 4 airlines serving from New York to West Tisbury

 
See real verified KAYAK customer reviews for airlines flying from New York to West Tisbury. Airline scores are aggregated from all reviews left by passengers on KAYAK after flying with an airline. KAYAK doesn’t show reviews that are older than 5 years. Learn how KAYAK collects reviews.
Need help choosing which airline to fly with from New York to West Tisbury? KAYAK airline reviews give an overall score for each airline based on loads of factors, including comfort, boarding, in-flight entertainment and more, to make your decision easier. See airline scores according to verified KAYAK customer reviews.
8.9
Cape AirOverall score based on 41 reviews
8.9Entertainment
8.5Comfort
9.3Crew
8.5Boarding
8.6Food
Airline reviews

It’s less complicated from Culebra to SJU airport. Next time I will prefer to leave from Isla Grande airport to Culebra !!

10.0 ExcellentSonia, Apr 2023CPX - SJU
Read more Cape Air reviews

It’s less complicated from Culebra to SJU airport. Next time I will prefer to leave from Isla Grande airport to Culebra !!

10 seat Cesna. Equal parts transportation and adventure. 20 minute hop at 10000 feet and 160 mph, sitting 10 feet from the pilot. Panoramic views of the island. Very simple boarding, very low stress. VQS airport tiny, undeveloped. Highly recommended flight, Cape Air doing a great job here.

We traveled in a small Cesna so there was no food or entertainment. The pilot was excellent enjoy being able to see the places we were flying above. It was an OK flight.

Very smooth flight and landing. Pilot delivered his safety instruction in such a monotone that it wasn’t easily understandable. Words were said but he didn't communicate to us. If he was communicating to someone he cared about, he would have used inflection and other nuances of speaking. Virtually all emphasis was removed so it was just blah blah blah (really fast, like the end of a Pharma commercial)

My pilot on Cape Air was AMAZING!!!! I hoping that next time I fly I have him as my pilot. He made me feel safe and secure in his skills.

I so appreciate this service into and out of Glendive. Always a good experience with crew and support team.

It was not what I had expected but it was a great way to see the landscape.

Pros: "ground crew, pilot, flight was smooth and gate connections to Jet Blue in Boston were fantastic!"
Cons: "leg room"
Pros: "The pilot was kind and to the point."
Cons: "The guy who boarded us told me to wait as his computer could not check me in. 10min later he is rushing me to get on the runway. It was 30min before scheduled take off. I had ordered food and had to cancel my order before the café had finished, so he wasted food and did not get paid and I was hurried and boarded the plane hungry. I probably won't use Cape Air again unless it's an emergency situation"
Cons: "Boarded half hour late. No explanation. Pretty standard on Cape Air these days"

The WiFi has been awful on my last few Delta Air Lines flights.

Only one side of the heafphone jack work. Crew was friendly and helpful.

It was reported to the passengers that Delta failed to schedule the crew properly. This error caused the pilot to show up about 30 minutes late. All in all Delta's inability to take care of this basic function resulted in about an hour delay.

Loyal Delta traveler, but last nights flight was a train wreck. Seated in 1B after multiple delays. Then we couldn’t takeoff because of an issue with the passenger that was ‘not in compliance’ and had to deplane along with the threat if they did not deplane, all the passengers would be required to do so. Finally they were escorted off, but the experience threw off the crew. Disruptive for everyone. Service was a mess, televisions didn’t work, bathroom door kept swinging open during the entire flight whenever empty …

Older plane and it came with Fleas and flea bites!

All good on Delta's part. Passengers could be a little more courteous to each other.

The fight was about 2 1/2 hours delayed, but that was weather related. The flight was also overbooked. But we were in Comfort plus so the flight was fine for us.

Awful. Flight was continuously getting delayed and gates kept changing without any reason. Flight was delayed for more then 3 hours

I'm a larger, athletic guy (6'2", 260lbs powerlifter) and I found the seats incredibly uncomfortable with minimal leg room, especially in a window seat. Now, I full understand that being smaller may change my view but even if I was 80lbs less, my legs would be the same size and I was sandwiched between my seat and the seat in front of me.

Seat back monitors and outlets were dead and not working.

Communication with the customer and stay is important. Staff off with a minor inconvenience but it worked out of course. Also this was a very old Mint Class plane. They snuck this one in on us. The updated aircraft are much better.

The flight itself was fine, but the boarding process was extremely frustrating. There is no one scanning boarding passes - passengers just scan themselves and enter the jetway. By the time my husband and I got on the plane and were halfway to our seats they determined there were too many bags on the plane and everything at that point needed to be checked. This created a lot of unnecessary chaos. They should have alerted people before getting on the plane that they would need to start checking bags instead of waiting until people were already on the plane.

In flight on demand didn't work at our seats. Only a single beverage/snack run.

Traveling with JetBlue from NYC was convenient as accessing JFK airport was straightforward via the LIRR to the AirTrain. Maneuvering through the terminal was hassle-free, which was a pleasant start to the journey. However, the flight experience itself left much to be desired. The seating arrangement was notably uncomfortable; despite securing a window seat, space felt cramped. This was exacerbated by the middle seat passenger encroaching on my area, which made the flight less enjoyable. Additionally, while the in-flight entertainment system initially seemed like a reprieve, the sound outlet on my seat was inoperable. This issue turned what could have been a manageable three-hour flight into a rather tedious ordeal, as I was unable to use the entertainment system effectively. While JetBlue provided a smooth process in terms of airport logistics, the on-board experience highlighted areas in need of improvement, particularly in terms of comfort and entertainment system maintenance.

Over 2 hour delay for a 50-minute flight is unacceptable, especially in normal weather. Very poor communication via app

Kayak sent over to jet blue my account being Mike Callaghan instead of Michael. I have a jet blue account with Michael that was connected

The flight was excellent. The crew was welcoming and attentive.

Going through JFK’s security is a mess. The TSA security said no shoes on the bins. So, we place our shoes in the belt and they came out all over the belt. Boarding was delayed and Flight as well.

There were multiple delays but JetBlue tried to make the boarding and departure process as quick and efficient as possible. The crew was as detached from reality as could be, meaning: not very friendly and just doing things by the numbers.

Jetblue needs to improve on Onboarding as it seems to always be behind on departing. It never leaves on time. I would recommend to have an earlier Onboarding in order to leave on time and respect your customers time as well.

The boarding process was incredibly slow, as was deplaning. They started beverage service and there was an extremely small amount of turbulence, so they discontinued it. They said they’d resume if possible, but even thought the rest of the flight was perfectly smooth, they didn’t bother. Getting our checked bags took longer than I’ve ever waited and they couldn’t even tell us which carousel they were coming out on, so everyone was running back and forth for 30 minutes.

It was really good. The boarding was good and smooth. They even checked our carry ons if you wanted to without any charge.

Flight was delayed , waited in the tarmac for 3 hours and then came back and was cancelled

Extreme weather delays. Missed my flight to France and I ended up leaving the plane.

I arrived to LaGuardia Airport 50 minutes prior to my 6am flight but was told that I was too late and would have to flight standby to Dallas in order reach my final destination of Jackson, MS. Hundreds of people were in my situation but the agents chalked this up to being normal for any day. Had my been able to board my original flight I would have arrived at my destination by 10:30am. I didn’t arrive until 7:30pm which included a 30 minute wait on the tarmac. Strangely my luggage arrived at my final destination at 12:30pm of the same travel day. This was by far the worst travel experience I’ve ever had.

The food was horrible compared to other airlines, there was no space for the overhead bins for carry-on luggage, and the seats were very uncomfortable.

I got food poisoning - lasted 4 days after starting medications - someone should check with food delivery.

They were not helpful in letting my baby and I rebook a flight early in the day when it was clear we were going to miss my connection (we did). The seats are much smaller than I remember. I did not get the option to board early with my toddler. I was flying solo with her and that would have been a big help.

On an overnight flight people behind me kept lively and loud conversation, which meant I couldn’t sleep. Food was really lousy, im sorry to say.

I am very disappointed with american. We have flown American airlines numerous times, as well as other airlines and never had such an experience. My son's flight for Sunday afternoon was cancelled around 11 am. We were told not to do anything bec AA would. After an hour of not seeing a change in his flight status. I called AA. I was on hold for half hour then opted for a call back. That call back never came. So I called again, in meantime I started looking online at my options. No flights were leaving that day from AA. But other airlines were flying out. We needed our son in Chicago asap.i kept calling AA for a callback, but never received one. Finally i called back later in the afternoon and a representative answered the call. She told me there were no flights out till Tuesday morning. I asked how this is possible, I had seen flights from AA and other airlines leaving Monday. She said she checked all NYC airports and there were no AA flights till Tuesday AM. Then I asked about getting on another airline. She responded i would be responsible for that. When I asked how AA would reimburse. She became nasty and told me AA has not responsibility to reimburse anything they will put me in a flight for Tuesday morning. When i explained he must be there Monday by 8am, she told me there's nothing to do and practically hung up. At that point I just asked her to book the Tuesday morning flight. I had this experience with other airlines, cancelled due to weather and they and their reps were much more helpful. Either way Tuesday morning flight was delayed as well. Over an hour! I expect more from AA.

Book cheap flights from New York to West Tisbury

Recent one-way flight deals

 
Only flying one-way? Below are some of the best one-way flight deals from New York to West Tisbury found on KAYAK in the last 72 hours.
5/3Sat
1 stopJetBlue
4h 20mJFK-MVY
$207
12/4Wed
1 stopJetBlue
3h 50mJFK-MVY
$237
12/4Wed
1 stopJetBlue
3h 50mLGA-MVY
$237
5/3Sat
1 stopJetBlue
3h 46mLGA-MVY
$247
12/5Thu
1 stopJetBlue
4h 00mJFK-MVY
$277
12/5Thu
1 stopJetBlue
5h 31mLGA-MVY
$277
2/3Mon
2 stops
6h 43mLGA-MVY
$302
1/2Thu
nonstopCape Air
1h 13mJFK-MVY
$410
12/1Sun
1 stopCape Air
19h 03mJFK-MVY
$431
11/18Mon
2 stopsCape Air
6h 10mJFK-MVY
$459

Search by stops

Search by airline

Search by price

Last minute flights from New York to West Tisbury

Last minute flight, train and bus deals

 
These last-minute flight deals are the cheapest flights found on KAYAK in the last 72 hours for flights from New York to West Tisbury that are departing in the next 10 days.
11/5Tue
multi-stop
10h 55mEWR-MVY
11/8Fri
multi-stop
21h 30mMVY-EWR
$751
11/5Tue
multi-stop
4h 48mEWR-MVY
11/8Fri
multi-stop
17h 33mMVY-EWR
$776
11/8Fri
multi-stopJetBlue
4h 00mLGA-MVY
11/10Sun
multi-stopJetBlue
2h 57mMVY-LGA
$813
11/8Fri
multi-stop
4h 00mEWR-MVY
11/10Sun
multi-stop
13h 59mMVY-EWR
$839
11/8Fri
multi-stopJetBlue
3h 00mJFK-MVY
11/10Sun
multi-stopJetBlue
3h 40mMVY-JFK
$848
11/8Fri
multi-stopJetBlue
3h 00mJFK-MVY
11/10Sun
nonstopJetBlue
1h 23mMVY-JFK
$861
11/9Sat
nonstopJetBlue
1h 13mJFK-MVY
11/10Sun
nonstopJetBlue
1h 23mMVY-JFK
$898
11/9Sat
multi-stopCape Air
20h 10mJFK-MVY
11/10Sun
multi-stopCape Air
15h 25mMVY-JFK
$910
11/8Fri
multi-stopCape Air
21h 41mJFK-MVY
11/10Sun
multi-stopCape Air
15h 25mMVY-JFK
$955
11/9Sat
multi-stopCape Air
20h 10mJFK-MVY
11/10Sun
multi-stopCape Air
18h 55mMVY-JFK
$1,027

Search by stops

Search by airline

Search by price

Everything you need to know for your flight from New York to West Tisbury

Information on your arrival and departure airports